Best Sandwiches in Eatontown, NJ

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in **Eatontown, NJ** at **115 NJ-35**

Where Every Sandwich Starts with Baked-Right Bread.

Order online

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Big City Sandwiches 🥪

Big City Sandwiches in Eatontown, NJ serves real food made fresh every day. We bake Brooklyn-sourced bread in-house, use fresh deli meats, and partner with local suppliers. We're a small, family-run spot that keeps things simple and done right. No chain vibes—just honest food and friendly service. Our 90s-style black and white floors and casual space make it easy to relax and enjoy. Stop by for a no-stress meal that’s fast, fresh, and made with care.

A Look Inside Big City Sandwiches

Step into our clean, casual space with a 90s retro vibe and black-and-white flooring. It’s a laid-back spot where good food and friendly service come together.

A Sandwich Shop That Keeps It Real 🧀

At Big City Sandwiches, we stick to what we know — Italian-style sandwiches, subs, and deli classics. Our bread is a big deal, and we make sure it’s fresh out of the oven each day. Once it’s warm and ready, we build your sandwich using local meats, cheeses, and veggies. That means every bite has ingredients you can trust. No shortcuts. No frozen stuff. Just solid sandwiches that fill you up and leave you feeling good. It’s the kind of food that makes people come back again and again.

Explore Our Menu

Fresh Off the Line

Check out our food gallery to see what we’re serving up daily — stacked sandwiches, fresh-baked bread, and all the real ingredients that make Big City Sandwiches a local favorite.

Order from Our Website

Getting your favorite sandwich has never been easier. Skip the wait and order straight from our website for quick pickup or delivery. Just a few clicks and your meal is on the way — fresh bread, local ingredients, and made just how you like it. Fast, simple, and ready when you are.

Order Now

Catering Made Easy 🍴

Feeding a group? Let Big City Sandwiches handle it. Our catering is perfect for meetings, parties, or any get-together. We use the same fresh bread, quality meats, and local ingredients you know and love. Just place your order, and we’ll take care of the rest — no stress, no mess, just good food that everyone can enjoy.

Build Your Spread

Grab Some Gear 🧢

Show your love for Big City Sandwiches with gear from our merch shop. From hats to tees, everything is made for comfort and built to last. It’s a simple way to support local and rep your favorite sandwich spot wherever you go. Pick up items in-store or check our site for new drops. Great food, great merch — all in one place.

Wear the Flavor

What our guests are saying

If you are looking for a place to get a sandwich, Big City should be the first place that comes to mind. Amazing food and outstanding service. You feel like family when you walk in. The Facia Bella and the Yo Adrien! have been my personal favorites but you really can’t go wrong with any choice.

Evan R.

This place was absolutely fabulous! By far the best sandwiches around! The food was all so fresh and the bread was amazing (chef’s kiss) My kids loved the mac n cheese and hot cheetoh fries. Everything was delicious and the service was top tier! The place was so clean and everyone was so friendly and warm! Love it!

Virginia S.

Absolutely delicious sandwiches. Huge portions & quality ingredients. My favorites are the chopped cheese, cheesesteak dipalma, and the vesuvio. Don’t forget about their sides too. The cracked Mac lives up to the name, and the disco fries are classic. Go check out big city sandwiches and thank me later!